Google Video (beta)

By Troy Dreier, CNET.com on 09/02/2006

More Google reviews , RRP: TBA

The good:

  • Hosts thousands of titles, most of them free, which are viewable online on Windows or Macintosh PCs.
  • Most free videos can be downloaded in video iPod- or PSP-compatible formats
  • Does feature some decent commercial content, including CBS programs.

The bad:

  • Almost no organisation of content
  • Paid content comes in a wide range of prices
  • Paid content is in a proprietary format, is not transferable to any portable devices at this point, and requires Google Video Player, which works only on Windows 2000 and XP systems.

The bottomline:

It turns out that an open, sprawling interface works better for a search engine than a video store. Google Video will have to take a few categorisation notes from Yahoo if it's ever going to challenge the iTunes Music Store.

Users' rating:

7.4/10

Tags:

beta | google | media | movie | online | store | video

This review will probably need updating quickly, because we can't imagine a company as successful and motivated as Google leaving a high-profile product in a state such as this for long. Google's entry into the online video marketplace looks rushed, and it lacks organisation, ease, and any forethought about how people shop.

Unmistakably a Google product, the video store has the company's signature sparse, white interface with an emphasis on searching, rather than Yahoo-like categorisation. The top of the home page features commercial content from CBS, BMG music, and others, offering well-known names such as Survivor, CSI, and NBA basketball. As of the posting of this review, you can even browse and play back all commercials shown during Super Bowl XL. Lower on the page, you'll find selections of popular and random free videos. A quick browse will uncover a gigantic library of video clips and shows.


The Google Video home page.

It's with paid content that Google Video mostly misses the mark. Videos can range in price dramatically, from US 99 cents to US$14.99, instead of a standard price; the iTunes Music Store charges US$1.99 for videos (iTunes video content is AU$3.39 in Australia). More expensive shows can often be purchased for less with a day pass, for those who are content to watch a show but not own it. Purchased content is available only to Windows 2000 and XP users and is in a proprietary GVI format, which can be played only with Google's free, no-frills player and can't be transferred to a portable device. With restrictions such as that, it's obvious that Google misunderstood why the iTunes Music Store's video sales made such a splash.


The no-frills Google Video player.

With free content, Google Video is more successful, although it's no more than a time-killing diversion. Users can post their own videos to the store, which are free to view, although within a few weeks, people will be able to charge for them (good luck). Free content can be viewed through Internet Explorer, Firefox, or Safari on any Windows or Macintosh computer, and most of it can be downloaded in AVI for either Windows or Mac computers; or in the correct format for PlayStation Portables or video iPods. Some pages have icons for sending the listing to a friend or adding the video to your Web site, but not all of them do.


Google Video hosted " People I Met Down Under" made on a Motorola v635 mobile phone by CNET.com.au's Munir Kotadia.

Google won't say how many titles are on the site, except that the number is in the thousands. With no organisation to the store, you're left browsing commercial or popular content, or searching on keywords. It's an entertaining way to spend some time, and the inclusion of so much free content is a smart idea, but with so little organisation, it's hard to discover interesting content in the store.

We didn't experience any major problems using the site or purchasing video, although purchases downloaded far too slowly. One 30-minute program took 20 minutes to download. Also, the Google Video player is far too simple, with no way to view your library of titles.

If you're having problems, Google Video offers several FAQs online, as well as a page to e-mail a question.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Phruargh
26/03/2008, 12:30 AM

rating
3
/10

make it easier to download what i want

Pros: measy to see what i want

Cons: hard to get what i want

Report offensive comment

deedee
25/09/2007, 08:10 PM

rating
10
/10

hi like this software

Report offensive comment

Cakes777
02/02/2007, 02:06 PM

rating
10
/10

Love It. Way better Than YouTube, mostly because of the Pro.

Pros: Download free videos.

Cons: No iPod videos for videos on sale.

Report offensive comment

manoj_bhatia
21/12/2006, 07:03 AM

rating
2
/10

wuts d use when u cant save d content

Report offensive comment

coreey247
21/11/2006, 08:22 AM

rating
10
/10

i think this will be good for downloading free movies.

Report offensive comment


06/10/2006, 09:35 AM

rating
10
/10

sdf asfsdaf

sdf

Pros: sdf

Cons: sdf

Report offensive comment


08/08/2006, 07:05 AM

rating
7
/10

Its great, but hate the fact you can copy the content.

Pros: Alot of ressources, massive library.

Cons: Contents c'ant be copyed to the hard drive and transfered to something that is editable... It would be great to have access to such a big library and be able to do what you want with the content. I'm really upset with this...

Report offensive comment

  • Leave a comment

All fields marked with * are required

What do you think

Rate this product:

Need help? Read our guidelines for what each number rating represents.

Your e-mail will not be displayed

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

You must read and type the 6 chars.

  • How Seven blew the internet Olympics

  • ABC's Web TV a hit

  • Free Speed: Make your Mac faster

  • Apple fixes security issues with QuickTime 7.5

  • Oi!: Brand Tags' clouds cut through marketing hype

  • Google offers YouTube video software for Macs

  • Adobe moves to broaden Flash reach

  • What's next for Flickr video?

  • Videophlow tries to enliven YouTube

More articles »

Find the right software

Brand
  • Multiple options can be selected

    The Explain Series

    • Roxio Easy Media Creator 10

      Roxio Easy Media Creator 10

      There's not much you can't do with Roxio's Easy Media Creator 10 Suite, although we'd dearly like to see more of the applications play nicely with each other.

    • Dazzle DVD Recorder DVC 100

      Dazzle DVD Recorder DVC 100

      Got old home movies gathering dust and mould? The DVC-100 offers a stress-free way to archive them to DVD for posterity, although critically it doesn't really do much more than that.

    • Pinnacle Studio 11

      Pinnacle Studio 11

      Pinnacle's Studio Ultimate offers a nice bridging gap product for those with low or high end video shooting equipment but little knowledge in video editing. Its Activation process is a royal pain, and set-up is likewise fiddly, but it ranks amongst the best in its class for ease-of-use video editing.

    • Apple iLife '08

      Apple iLife '08

      Apple iLife '08 is a fine, affordable media-editing suite that should keep beginners and hobbyists happy when managing pictures, videos, songs and podcasts, but those seeking to fine-tune movies should look elsewhere.

    • Apple Final Cut Studio 2

      Apple Final Cut Studio 2

      Final Cut Studio 2 is a solid value and worthy upgrade for serious film editors who work on Macs. However, hobbyists should consider simpler software.

    More reviews »

    Membership benefits

    Contact community members

    Contact community members

    Add friends or tech gurus to you contacts and send them messages. Sign up for a free CNET.com.au membership now!